Greater Manchester Police (GMP) is the worst force in England and Wales for not finding suspects for hate crimes.
Home Offices figures show the force shutting 46% of cases with no-one in the frame.
The figures released related to offences from September 2017 until September last year.
West Midlands Police (WMP) had the second highest number with 44%.
GMP said it recognised it has "a way to go to reassure communities". WMP said it was determined to "trace suspects".
Tribute paid to hospital radio legend Patrick Murphy
Bradford Council reports strong progress on financial recovery
Bradford nurseries recognised with elite ‘900 Club’ award
Teenager injured in Dewsbury bus station stabbing as three arrested
Seven Jailed for Over 40 Years in Halifax Drugs Crackdown
Twelve Charged Over Non-Recent Child Sexual Offences in Calderdale
Bradford Cathedral Hosts ‘Triangle of Unity’ Exhibition
Muslim Aid Launches Winter Support for Vulnerable Communities
Bold 2036 Vision Set to Shape Future of Halifax
Alim OnAir
Legal Show
Bhangra Nights
Remix Saturdays